Saint Paul rent stabilization appeals, May 2022 to Nov. 4, 2026: every appeal file, and rental units affected by month Last updated: Nov. 4, 2026 Published by the Twin Cities Renter Guide, twincitiesrenterguide.com. WHAT THIS IS Every rent stabilization appeal that reached the Saint Paul City Council's Legislative Hearing Officer since the ordinance took effect, and how each ended. The detail file has everything in the public Legistar record except people's names: file numbers and links, dates, addresses and units, who appealed, the increases asked for and allowed, the landlord's net operating income (MNOI) figures where we have them, the hearing officer's recommendation, the council's action and vote, the main reasons and the document behind each value. People's names (tenants, attorneys, private individual owners, staff) are replaced by a role, such as [Tenant] or [Private owner]. Company and organization names stay. From May 2022 to Nov. 4, 2026, appeals involved 1,655 rental units in 26 buildings (41 appeal files); the appeals themselves decided the increase for 56 units. Of the rental units affected, appeals were won for 444, partly won for 221 and denied for 805; 1 were in appeals withdrawn, dismissed or sent back to the city, and 184 are pending. FILES - saint-paul-rent-stabilization-appeals-detail.csv: one row per Legistar file (43 files, including 2 that continue an earlier file). saint-paul-rent-stabilization-appeals-detail-dictionary.csv explains each column. - saint-paul-rent-stabilization-appeals-monthly.csv: rental units affected, units decided and appeal files by month, year and all time, with the outcome split for all appeals, tenant appeals and landlord appeals. saint-paul-rent-stabilization-appeals-monthly-dictionary.csv explains each column. - data/rs-appeals.json: the same numbers in the shape the charts read. SOURCE City of Saint Paul Legistar (stpaul.legistar.com): every rent stabilization appeal file (RLH RSA) since May 1, 2022, with its hearing minutes, the Legislative Hearing Officer's recommendation, the City Council's action, and the attached determination letters, worksheets and letters. The rows to Nov. 4, 2026, were checked by hand against the documents. After that, a weekly automatic pull adds new files; their percentages, MNOI figures and unit counts wait for a check by hand ("checked" says which). HOW WE COUNTED - Rental units affected: the units covered by the city's decision (determination) that was appealed, from the determination letter or the landlord's maintenance of net operating income worksheet. Several appeal files about the same determination (for example, one per unit in the same building) are one determination, and its units count once a year, in the month of the first appeal that year. - Rental units decided: the units whose own increase the appeal decided. Tenants appeal for their own unit, so a tenant appeal usually decides one unit, even when the whole building got the increase. - Each rental unit is roughly one household. A unit can hold several people, or be vacant, so this counts homes, not people. - An appeal counts in the month it was filed, not the month it was decided. The city's own yearly table (records request D111610, also on this site) counts by year decided, so its years differ. - Outcome is the City Council's final action. For units affected, a determination counts as won if any of its appeals was granted, partly won if any was granted in part, and so on. - A second file for the same appeal (a refiling, or a file reopened after a court remand) is listed but not counted again. PRIVACY (Nov. 4, 2026) Appeals are public City Council records, so outcomes are shown for every month. Names are replaced by roles before anything leaves our server, and a file that still holds a name from the server's private name list is not published. The list is never published. CAVEATS - Small numbers. A few appeals a month can swing a lot, and one large building can dominate a month. - Appeals are a small slice of rent stabilization: most requests to go above 3% never reach the council. The city's request records (D135699, pending) will add that layer, counted the same way (units in each request). - Since June 13, 2025, buildings first occupied after 2004 are exempt, so they no longer produce requests or appeals. - MNOI figures from scanned documents were read by OCR and checked by hand; the source column says which document. OPENING THE FILES The CSV files are UTF-8 text. In Excel, use Data > From Text/CSV, choose UTF-8, and set ID columns (parcel, license, block and precinct codes) to Text; opened by double-click, long numbers lose digits and leading zeros and some punctuation can look wrong. LICENSE CC BY-NC 4.0 (Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/). Credit: "Source: Twin Cities Renter Guide (twincitiesrenterguide.com), CC BY-NC 4.0." Commercial use needs written permission; news reporting, research, teaching, government use and nonprofit organizing are already allowed with credit. USE RULE (part of the guide's terms): don't use this data to harass, dox, threaten or target anyone, to discriminate against renters, or for anything illegal. Pass this rule along if you share it. The public records behind this file belong to their publishers (listed above) and follow their terms. Full terms: https://twincitiesrenterguide.com/#terms-of-use